Guides and Tips
Energy Performance Certificates in mountainous and high-altitude areas: why the ratings differ from those on the coast
6 min read
Many buyers compare the energy performance certificate (EPC) of a property in the Verdon or the Alpes-de-Haute-Provence with that of a property on the coast, and are concerned about the difference. This difference is largely a matter of calculation: the EPC depends on the climate, and therefore on the altitude. Here’s how to interpret it correctly so you can buy, sell or invest with confidence.
The DPE depends on the climate, and therefore on the altitude
The energy performance assessment (3CL-DPE method) does not merely measure the quality of the building: it calculates conventional energy consumption, which is overwhelmingly dominated by heating. The colder it is, the longer the building needs to be heated throughout the year.
The method is therefore based on climate data that depend on the municipality’s climate zone — from the coldest (H1, in the Alpine interior) to the mildest (H3, on the Mediterranean coast) — and on altitude, with different bands (generally up to 400 m, from 400 to 800 m, and above 800 m). The higher the altitude, the harsher the reference climate, and the higher the theoretical consumption.
Why are mountain homes often judged more harshly?
Take two semi-detached houses: one at low altitude, the other at 1,300 metres in the Upper Verdon. Same insulation, same heating system. The second will almost always be given a lower energy performance rating – not because it is ‘worse’, but because the energy performance certificate assigns it a higher theoretical heating requirement.
Conversely, on the coast (zone H3, mild winters), a property is more likely to achieve a B or a C rating. Comparing the raw score of a mountain property with that of a seaside property therefore doesn’t really make sense: the starting conditions are not the same.
What this really means for you
To make a fair comparison, stick to properties in similar climates: a ‘D’ rating at altitude may correspond to a much better-built property than a ‘C’ rating on the coast. And actual comfort isn’t just about the energy efficiency rating — mountain homes are designed for the cold (thick walls, wood-burning stoves or boilers, carefully chosen orientations), and their running costs are often lower than the rating suggests.
Investors and letting: it all depends on the type of tenancy. The ‘energy efficiency’ thresholds (F and G), which are gradually being used to restrict letting, apply to unfurnished or furnished annual lets (where the tenant’s main residence is located) — not to traditional holiday lets. This is good news for projects involving gîtes or furnished holiday accommodation, which are very common in the Verdon and the Alpes-de-Haute-Provence.
Please note, however, that since the end of 2024, a specific framework for holiday lettings (the so-called ‘Le Meur’ Act) has begun to introduce its own energy performance certificate (EPC) requirements, which vary from one local authority to another. This is therefore not an automatic exemption: please check the local regulations relevant to your project. Properties in mountainous areas, which are inherently more vulnerable in terms of energy efficiency ratings, would be well advised to plan ahead on this point.
Improving the Energy Performance Certificate (EPC) of a property at high altitude
A poor energy rating is not inevitable, and the key measures are well known: insulation is the top priority (roof and loft, then walls); this is the most effective measure in cold climates; a heating system suited to low temperatures (a heat pump designed for cold weather, or a high-efficiency boiler or wood-burning stove); well-fitted windows and doors and good airtightness, along with controlled ventilation to prevent damp.
Government grants are available depending on the work involved and the circumstances, and a few well-targeted measures can improve a property’s energy rating by one or more classes. Benoît Bravet helps you to put the energy rating into its climate context, to assess a property’s true potential for improvement, and to present its performance honestly to prospective buyers.
Talk to us
Common Questions
Because the Energy Performance Certificate (EPC) takes climate and altitude into account: a colder location results in a higher theoretical heating requirement, and therefore a lower rating, for an identical building.
